Hyundai Rotem Company (Appellant) v. ACIT (Respondent)
ITA No.510/Del./2016 dated 22/11/2017
M/s. Hyundai Rotem Company, the taxpayer, paid an amount to DMRC out of the remittance received from the Head office.
But, Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) had the view that Associated Enterprises (AE) reimbursed the taxpayer as a usual Head Office would support its Project office.
Further, he also held that because the payment arose from taxpayer’s business in India so the transaction should form the part of the margin calculation.
Whether the payment of arbitration award forms part of margin calculation to be added to revenue and cost for bench marking the international transaction?
VIEW OF PANEL
In an order passed by DRP under Rule 13 of the Income-tax Rules, 2009, panel after carefully examining the matter found that the arbitration award was in respect of payment of customs and excise duty exemptions granted by the Government of India.
As per the panel if the liabilities of payment of custom duty and service tax are of project office, then the amount spent on payment of custom duties and service tax and thus also the expense on payment of arbitration award, will be part of cost base of the assesse for purpose of mark-up, if not then it would not be so included.
TPO was directed to follow consistent policy in respect of treatment of these reimbursement and the reimbursement of the arbitration award.
ITAT agreed with the decision of the panel and directed TPO to follow the rule of consistency.
It held that payment on account of arbitration award cannot form part of the cost base for purpose of margin calculation.
Disclaimer and Confirmation
As per the Rules of the Bar Council of India, advocates are not permitted to advertise. By clicking on the “I agree” button, the user agrees and acknowledges that:
This website simply explains as to how litigation is handled, the advice is rendered for various practice areas of the firm and how our law firm i.e. AMLEGALS does it differently;
That the user has visited the website of our law firm to know about AMLEGALS, White Papers, Legal articles, Legal updates & Case laws on various areas of law that are published by the Firm from time to time.
AMLEGALS assumes no liability for the interpretation and/or use of the information contained on this website, nor does it offer a warranty of any kind, either express or implied.
AMLEGALS is not liable for any consequences of any action taken by the user by relying on material/information provided on this website. Nothing mentioned on the website should be construed as legal advice. For more information on our working and to get in touch with the AMLEGALS team, please feel free to get in touch on firstname.lastname@example.org.