
Introduction
The power of compulsory retirement enables the Government to retire an employee in public interest where the competent authority, upon examining the service record, considers that continued retention is not conducive to administrative efficiency. However, the exercise of this power remains subject to judicial review where the decision is arbitrary, mala fide, perverse or unsupported by relevant material.
In Chatur Singh Dhruw v. State of Chhattisgarh and Others (Civil Appeals arising out of SLP(C) Nos. 24392 and 25201 of 2023), the Supreme Court of India, comprising Justice Manmohan and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar, upheld the compulsory retirement of two employees of the Chhattisgarh Legal Metrology Department. The Court held that non-retirement of another similarly situated employee does not, by itself, establish discrimination. It also clarified that uncommunicated adverse entries may be considered while assessing an employee’s suitability for compulsory retirement.
The judgment reiterates the distinction between compulsory retirement in public interest and disciplinary action, and the limited scope of judicial interference in such decisions.
Factual Background
The appellants, Chatur Singh Dhruw and Manharan Lal Sahu, were appointed as Peons (Class IV) in the Legal Metrology Department, Raipur, in 1989 and 1993, respectively. They were promoted to Assistant Grade-III on 14 March 2013 and 3 October 2012, respectively, and their services were regularised by separate orders dated 19 June 2015.
On 25 April 2017, the General Administration Department, Government of Chhattisgarh, issued a circular directing the review of service records of government employees who had completed 20 years of qualifying service or attained 50 years of age. The prescribed criteria included honesty, integrity, physical capacity, reputation, work efficiency and the overall service record, including whether performance during the preceding five years was declining.
Pursuant to the circular, a Screening Committee examined the service records of 14 eligible employees and recommended five, including the appellants, for compulsory retirement. The Committee adopted a numerical grading system for assessing confidential reports. Consequently, orders dated 9 October 2017 were issued compulsorily retiring the appellants under Fundamental Rule 56 and Rule 42(1)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976.
The appellants challenged the orders before the Chhattisgarh High Court. The Single Judge dismissed their writ petitions on 23 August 2019, and the Division Bench affirmed the decision on 12 April 2023. The appellants thereafter approached the Supreme Court.
Contentions Before the Court
The appellants contended that the criteria for compulsory retirement had not been uniformly applied, as other employees with comparable service records had been retained. They further argued that the orders were punitive and stigmatic and that compulsory retirement had been used to circumvent disciplinary proceedings.
It was also submitted that the authorities had failed to consider their entire service records and had primarily relied upon the ACRs for the preceding five years. Since the adverse entries and below-benchmark gradings had not been communicated, the appellants relied on Dev Dutt v. Union of India, (2008) 8 SCC 725, and Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India, (2013) 9 SCC 566. Relying on Baikuntha Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer, Baripada, (1992) 2 SCC 299, they further argued that their promotions and regularisation had rendered the earlier adverse entries insignificant.
The State submitted that all 14 eligible employees had been assessed uniformly in accordance with the circular dated 25 April 2017. It maintained that the Committee had considered their complete service records, integrity, physical fitness, efficiency and confidential reports before recommending five employees for compulsory retirement.
Scope of Judicial Review
The Supreme Court reiterated that compulsory retirement is neither punitive nor stigmatic. An order passed in public interest under the applicable service rules does not attract the principles of audi alteram partem or the protection under Article 311(2) of the Constitution. The Court observed that compulsory retirement is based on the subjective satisfaction of the competent authority regarding the employee’s continued utility in public service. Such satisfaction, however, must be bona fide and founded on relevant material, and cannot rest on conjecture or whim.
Relying on Nand Kumar Verma v. State of Jharkhand, (2012) 3 SCC 580, the Court held that judicial review is limited to examining whether relevant material existed and was considered, and whether a reasonable person could have arrived at the conclusion. Courts cannot reappreciate or reweigh the material as an appellate authority. Interference is warranted where the decision is based on no evidence, reflects non-application of mind, is manifestly arbitrary or perverse, or is vitiated by mala fides.
Equal Treatment and Individual Assessment
Rejecting the appellants’ contention that other employees with comparable service records had been retained, the Court held that compulsory retirement requires an individual assessment of each employee’s service record. The retention of another employee does not, by itself, establish discrimination. The Court reiterated that Article 14 embodies positive equality and does not recognise negative equality. An employee cannot rely on an alleged illegality or omission in another case to claim similar treatment.
On examining the records, the Court found that all 14 employees had been assessed under the same criteria. The nine employees retained in service did not exhibit the same combination of adverse factors as the appellants, namely, an overall assessment below Grade B, sustained C gradings between 2013 and 2017 without discernible improvement, and adverse remarks concerning efficiency and performance. The Committee had also recommended three other employees for compulsory retirement. The Court accordingly found no selective application of the prescribed criteria. Service Records, Promotion and Adverse Entries
The Supreme Court rejected the contention that the Screening Committee had failed to consider the appellants’ entire service records. It found that the Committee had first examined the complete records and thereafter considered the ACRs for 2013 to 2017 as an ancillary and corroborative exercise to identify declining performance. This was consistent with the circular dated 25 April 2017, which specifically required consideration of performance during the preceding five years.
The Court also rejected the argument that promotion had rendered the adverse entries irrelevant. Relying on Baikuntha Nath Das (supra), it clarified that adverse entries preceding a promotion may lose their significance where they are deemed to have been overlooked while granting the promotion. However, this principle does not extend to adverse entries recorded after promotion, particularly those relating to performance in the promoted post.
In the present case, Chatur Singh Dhruw received an A grading in 2013, followed by C gradings from 2014 to 2017. Manharan Lal Sahu also received repeated C gradings during 2013 to 2017, accompanied by remarks indicating unsatisfactory performance. Since these entries related to the period after their promotions, they remained relevant to assessing their continued suitability for service. The Court further clarified that regularisation is not equivalent to a merit-based promotion and does not amount to an endorsement of an employee’s efficiency or future suitability.
Non-Communication of Adverse Entries
The Court held that an order of compulsory retirement cannot be set aside merely because uncommunicated adverse entries were considered by the competent authority. It relied on Baikuntha Nath Das (supra) and distinguished Dev Dutt (supra) and Sukhdev Singh (supra), which concerned communication of ACR entries in the context of promotion and career progression.
The Court clarified that the principles in those decisions cannot be mechanically extended to compulsory retirement, which is governed by a distinct body of jurisprudence. Accordingly, non-communication of adverse entries, by itself, did not invalidate the orders.
Compulsory Retirement Is Not Disciplinary Action
The Supreme Court also rejected the contention that compulsory retirement had been used to circumvent disciplinary proceedings. The orders dated 9 October 2017 merely recorded that the appellants were being retired in public interest under the applicable service rules. They contained no allegation of misconduct or finding of culpability.
The Court further observed that internal deliberations of the Screening Committee do not, by themselves, render an order stigmatic. Significantly, no departmental inquiry was pending or contemplated against either appellant at the relevant time. The allegation that compulsory retirement had been adopted to avoid disciplinary proceedings was therefore unsupported by the record.
Dismissal of the Appeals
The Supreme Court concluded that the compulsory retirement process had been undertaken in accordance with the prescribed procedure and that the decision was based on relevant material. The appellants had failed to establish arbitrariness, mala fides, perversity or violation of any constitutional or statutory guarantee warranting judicial interference. Accordingly, the Court affirmed the judgments of the Chhattisgarh High Court and dismissed both appeals, with no order as to costs.
AMLEGALS Remarks
The judgment reiterates that compulsory retirement is an assessment of an employee’s continued utility in public service and is distinct from disciplinary action. While the competent authority has discretion to take such a decision in public interest, its satisfaction must be bona fide and based on relevant material.
The decision also clarifies that uncommunicated adverse entries may be considered for compulsory retirement, notwithstanding the principles governing communication of ACRs in matters of promotion. Further, promotion does not neutralise adverse entries recorded thereafter, and regularisation does not amount to an endorsement of an employee’s efficiency.
For any queries or feedback, feel free to connect with Hiteashi.desai@amlegals.com
